The Great Herring Disaster

*Darkness. A voice narrating. It sounds pompous, powerful, and slightly intoxicated.*

LO, AND A GREAT CRY WAS HEARD THROUGHOUT THE LAND… The rumbling voices of a thousand somewhat curious onlookers, riveted by the journey of two friends from simple American expats in Sweden to would-be picklers of Swedish fish.

AND WHAT A JOURNEY IT WAS. 

*Loud thundercrash, curtain draws back, revealing a grotesquely fat Tom Cruise, who is narrating*

Tom Cruise and the tale of the sainted herring. Photo: Screen grab from "Tropic of Thunder" plus some modifications

Listen, my children, and you will hear… Of a truly heinous story of herring gone wrong, and the terrible fate that awaits unsuspecting picklers.

*Thunder crashes again, cut away to FLASHBACK*

Once upon a time, there were two friends. Let’s call them Kate and Steve.

*Charming pastoral soundtrack*

The two friends lived in Sweden, and when National Day approached, they decided to go where no Swede had ever gone before: pickling their own herring. (When I say “where no Swede had ever gone before,” this is of course excluding everyone’s grandparents, all seafood chefs, fish markets, food distribution factories, and my friend Anna, who did it for Christmas a couple of years ago.)

Like I said, we dared to go WHERE NO SWEDE HAD E’ER GONE BEFORE.

We diced. We sliced. We skinned. We pickled.

And it was good.

The annual Midsummer feast, a tribute to nature and to fertility and to the land of the midnight sun, would be graced by a triumvirate of pickled wonders: one Senapssill, one Brantevik sill, one Leif Mannerström Unnamed “Classic Recipe” Sill.

The triumvirate of pickled wonders. Photos: Kate Reuterswärd

Once the pickling process was approximately perfect, we watched the jars with a keenness not unlike that of new parents. We marked incremental changes in the amount of fluid in the jars or the slight change in color of the sauces with equal parts joy and wonder.

This herring was going to be THE BEST HERRING EVER.

Until…

*cue Mr. Crowley guitar solo. The silhouette of the unknown guitarist is outlined by a crash of lightning and MORE THUNDER.*

The week of Midsummer came. Kate’s plans were still up in the air. Steve had rented a cottage outside of Ystad. The unthinkable happened.

How to interpret the following chain of events must be left to far more talented historians than I, a simple scribe.

Steve forgot to pick up the herring from Kate’s refrigerator. Or Kate forgot to bring the herring to Steve. Depending on how you see it.

And then Steve left for the cottage. And Kate went to Stockholm.

And the merry herring pickled on, jiving to the bacteria beat.

THE BACTERIA BEAT, YOU SAY? That doesn’t sound good.

Ahh, yes. What an apt observation. Because the bacteria beat is not good. The bacteria beat is so not good that it has even crossed over the border to being bad, BAD TO THE BONE, regardless of the fact that bacteria don’t have bones.

The word slithers out of your mouth: b o t u l i s m. 

NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The herring had already crossed over to the Dark Side, and unlike Darth Vader in his final moments, there was no winning it back.

Ye shall know the Fiskehoddorna when you see it, for a gigantic sculpture of something fishing-related has been placed in front of it. Photo: Kate Reuterswärd

Steve went to the Fiskehoddarna fish market in Malmö to consult with an expert. The grizzled man with snus-stained gums answered his questions with uninterested contempt.

Steve: We pickled our own herring from fresh fish about three weeks ago. Is it still good to eat?

The grizzled man: I wouldn’t.

And with that, our pickled herring journey was over. A mission that had to be abandoned without reaching our final destination, and one kilo of possibly Botulism-infected herring still left in my fridge as I try to figure out the best way to dispose of it.

Oh, the herring. 

  • Monica-USA

    Oh no, Kate that really sucks!! Well there is always next year to try again?! :o )

  • Fred

    I bet this is how surströmming was invented. Only they let it spoil for a year. Grand effort though.

  • http://woodge.com/ woodge

    Så synd!

  • dubium

    How did you get this bacteriaphobia in your head? Pickling is usually what you do just to preserve food. Ättikssprit (or some similar vinegar) kills bacteria and things like that. Dill and mustard also kills “microbials” like bacteria, mold, fungus or whatever. Did you actually see or smell the food go bad like getting moldy, green and smelly or did you just get paranoid? :)

    Pickled food are specially made just for the purpose not to go bad, atleast for several months. That is the whole reason why people pickle food, even more so back in the days. Fresh cucumber, lasts a week maybe? Pickled cucumber, lasts a year? Maybe forever?

    • http://www.transatlanticsketches.com Kate Reuterswärd

      That’s what I thought too, originally, but when I looked it up online, there were a lot of sources that said that unless the herring was pickled in a commercial facility, it would be spoiled after two weeks. I assumed that it was going to be good for a lot longer. It’s still unopened in the fridge. Do you have any sources that say we can eat it? Because that would be great.

      • dubium

        No sorry, i do not have any source that says that. I just babbled on as i usually do haha i was so sure that it was harmless but then i read about it and found similar information as you have done, apparantly. I did not know about how botulism works either. It seems as nobody is really sure, it can grow but some source said that Sweden have had only 11 cases of that bacteria in homemade food since 1969 and only four of them was related to anything pickled. Also eventhough it is very poisonous not very many seems to actually die from it. And it also says this bacteria is in the dirt and the water and everywhere. All in all, it all seems very uncertain and it is not good to read about if you are paranoid like me. I read most of that on wiki, i think.

        Whatever, do not listen to me i am no expert and i am torn between two views on this subject. On the one hand i am paranoid and scared of bacteria and stuff, on the other hand i think we should not be that afraid and it is often exaggerated. I mean people lived thousand of years not even knowing what a bacteria was haha and most of them survived. Also we do throwaway perfectly good food today and they say if stuff looks fine and smells fine, it is usually good. But still, i am uncertain. And rambling, as always, in any language. :)

        Maybe you could call or send a mail to “livsmedelsverket”, they are supposed to be experts on this i guess. Maybe they have some advice. They have a contact form and a number on their homepage. http://www.slv.se

        • http://www.transatlanticsketches.com Kate Reuterswärd

          Darn it, I was hoping you were going to send me something that would say I could go ahead and eat all the herring!

          I’m the same as you when it comes to germs and bacteria. When someone first suggested that it might not be good, I was like, “poo, germaphobes, of course it’s fine.” But then when I saw the photos of the people who had contracted botulism, I got a lot more nervous about going ahead and eating it myself. I mean, it would PROBABLY be fine, I sterilized the bottles and pickled it and everything. But maybe it won’t.

          I will definitely get in touch with livsmedelsverket. If nothing else, they’ll add another layer to this very strange story. :)

          Thanks for the suggestion! Best to you :)

          • Monica-USA

            I kind of thought that it was like canning something that it would last for quite some time and be safe. Like pickled beets, etc. because the vinegar is what makes it keep. But I would double check with Sweden’s version of the Health Department.

  • http://drinkinggames.me/bullshit/ David G.

    Ugh, have never been able to eat pickled fish, no matter how “good” a company (or person) made it. Maybe I’ve just been spoiled on it forever since trying some crappy stuff with my friends at Passover. Oh well, there’s always beer!